Case Study: General AI Chat vs Contractam — Notice Clause
Summary
On 18 November 2026, Contractam reviewed a termination clause that allowed an employer to end employment on three days’ written notice and required the employee to work those three days. Contractam flagged the clause as non-compliant on its first review. It identified the short notice period, explained why the ban on payment in lieu made the wording a problem and cited the provision of the Fair Work Act 2009 that a business could check.
The finding was then examined in a conversation with Claude, a general-purpose AI assistant. Across several replies, the discussion moved from the defect in the contract to proposed changes in four parts of Contractam’s report. Claude also drew a broad conclusion about whether a dismissed employee could leave the workplace that day. It withdrew that conclusion after the reviewer challenged its reasoning.
Contractam was the better first review for a team without an in-house lawyer. The first clause card gave the team enough information to hold the contract and identify what needed changing. Getting to a dependable conclusion in the chat required someone who already understood the issue well enough to challenge the answer.
What was tested and how
| Study detail | Description |
|---|---|
| Date | 18 November 2026 |
| Material examined | Clause 5 of an employment contract, covering notice of termination by the employer |
| First review | Contractam assessed the clause and produced a card with a legal verdict, a business risk rating, its reasoning and a legal reference. |
| Follow-up review | The reviewer used Claude to examine Contractam’s finding about the same clause and challenged the advice over several replies. |
| Question examined | What could a business owner decide from each output, and how much legal knowledge did the owner need to reach that decision? |
The sequence matters. Claude had a finding to examine, including the clause number and the relevant legislation. The comparison therefore captures two stages of a real contract review. It records what Contractam identified on its first pass and what happened when a general AI chat was used to check that work. One clause and one conversation support conclusions about this case. A broader accuracy comparison would require separate testing.
This case study follows the finding from the clause to the proposed action. Did the explanation identify which wording created the shortfall? Could a manager tell what to change in the contract? Could a second reader verify the reason without repeating the original conversation? Those questions reflect the work a small team has to do between receiving a review and approving an offer.
The clause and the legal position
Clause 5, in substance: the employer could end employment on three days’ written notice, regardless of length of service. The employee had to work that notice. The employer could not pay the employee instead.
The words regardless of length of service are central to the finding. For an employee covered by section 117 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth), the employer must give written notice specifying the termination date. The statutory notice period starts at one week for service of up to one year. It rises to two weeks after one year, three weeks after three years and four weeks after five years. An employee over 45 receives an additional week after completing at least two years of continuous service. Section 123 sets out exceptions, including casual employees and dismissal for serious misconduct. Fair Work Act 2009, sections 117 and 123
For example, a covered 47-year-old employee with four years of continuous service is entitled to at least four weeks’ notice. The template would give that person the same three days as a new starter. Even for a covered employee in their first week of employment, three days falls below the statutory minimum. A longer entitlement under an award, enterprise agreement or contract also needs to be checked. Fair Work Ombudsman guidance on notice of termination
The second sentence determines what a manager following the clause would do about the shortfall. Section 117 permits payment in lieu of notice, and Fair Work guidance also describes working part of the period and paying out the balance. Clause 5 allows the manager to end employment after three days and rules out paying that balance. Using the clause that way would leave a covered employee short. Fair Work Ombudsman guidance on dismissal
The first fix is the notice period. A requirement to work a sufficient notice period can comply with section 117. If the business also wants the option to end employment immediately and pay in lieu, its contract should address that choice. Meeting the statutory minimum does not automatically discharge a separate contractual promise to give working notice. Fair Work Ombudsman guidance on employment contracts · Sanders v Snell [1998] HCA 64, paragraphs 16–18
What happened in the general AI chat
The chat narrowed the question. Claude treated the payment restriction as a separate term and disputed the warning about it. A business can require an employee to work a sufficient notice period. The practical problem in this contract was that the only period it gave the employee to work was three days. Analysing the second sentence on its own removed the fact that made it consequential.
That reading produced four proposed edits. Claude recommended changes to Problems Found, Legal References, Why This Score and Impact on Business. It also suggested correcting the underlying review process. Those recommendations carried the same assumption into several parts of the report. A manager could reasonably read the four edits as separate reasons to doubt the finding, even though they all came from one disputed interpretation.
The chat overstated the operational consequence. It suggested the business could never have the employee leave the workplace on the day notice was given. Leaving the premises and ending employment are separate events. Clause 5 alone could not determine whether the employee had to attend the workplace that day, when employment could lawfully end or what payment the employer owed. Those questions depend on the contract and the circumstances.
The reviewer had to supply the missing connection. The replies were clearly written and referred to real legislation. Their presentation gave the reader little reason to question the proposed changes. Claude revised its position after the reviewer brought the three-day period and the payment restriction back together. For a team buying a first contract review, that is a material dependency. The person checking the answer needed to know which point to challenge.
What Contractam produced
| Clause 5 card | Recorded output |
|---|---|
| Legal verdict | Non-compliant |
| Business risk | Critical |
| Main defect | Three days’ notice falls below the section 117 minimum for a covered employee. |
| Effect of the second sentence | The contract also rules out paying for the notice the employee would miss. |
| Legal reference | Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth), section 117 |
| Business implications flagged | A claim for the notice shortfall, possible penalties and difficulty planning a departure under the wording as drafted. |
| Analysis confidence | 98%, the score displayed for this finding |
The card kept the legal finding separate from its business priority. Non-compliant identified the problem with relying on the clause. Critical told the person approving the contract how urgently Contractam considered it needed attention. The potential exposure would arise if the business acted on the wording and failed to meet its obligations. The review examined a contract clause. It did not document a dismissal, underpayment or penalty. Fair Work Ombudsman guidance on ending employment
The card omitted the extra week for eligible employees over 45. That detail matters when drafting the replacement clause or calculating an individual entitlement. It also illustrates why the section reference is more valuable to an owner than the confidence percentage alone. A colleague can open the provision, check the age adjustment and retain the original, well-founded decision to hold the contract.
Why the review method made a difference
| Feature | General AI chat in this case | Contractam in this case |
|---|---|---|
| How the issue was examined | The question and follow-up replies shaped which part of the wording received attention. | The clause review considered the notice period and payment restriction together. |
| Use of legal sources | The replies cited the Act. The case record does not establish how Claude obtained the reference. | Contractam’s process linked the clause to the official legal source and displayed section 117 with the finding. |
| How a verdict was reached | Legal interpretation, suggested edits and operational advice appeared across several replies. | A dedicated legal assessment produced the compliance verdict. The card reported business risk separately. |
| What another person could check | A colleague would need to follow the exchange to see which conclusions the reviewer challenged. | The clause number, verdict, reason and authority appeared together in the first report. |
Contractam describes separate checks for legality, pay, clarity, fairness and legal principles. Only its legal assessment can mark a clause non-compliant. That distinction mattered here. An employer might prefer working notice for a client handover. Whether that preference suits the business is a different question from whether three days meets the legal minimum. A structured report can give each question its proper place. Contractam’s contract review method
Why Contractam was better for a team without in-house legal support
The first advantage was knowing when to stop. The person preparing the offer could see which clause blocked approval and why. They could hold the template before another offer went out, without first researching the meaning of payment in lieu or working out how to phrase a follow-up prompt.
The second was being able to explain the decision to a colleague. The hiring manager, business owner and payroll officer could all work from the same finding. Hiring could identify other offers using Clause 5. The owner could decide whether the business wanted the flexibility to pay out notice. Payroll could check the applicable period, rate and payment date before anyone relied on the wording for an actual departure.
That division of work matters if the clause has already been used. A manager can identify the affected contract and gather the notice letter and pay records. Those documents give the adviser a basis for checking what actually happened. A warning on the template alone cannot tell the business how much an individual employee is owed.
The third was giving an external lawyer a focused brief. The team could supply the contract, point to Clause 5 and ask two concrete questions. What notice entitlement must this template preserve? How should it be written if the business wants the option of a worked handover or payment in lieu? That gives the lawyer both the legal issue and the commercial decision the wording needs to support.
In this test, the decisive difference was what the business knew before anyone pushed back. Contractam’s first card identified a defect serious enough to hold the contract, the two sentences responsible and the law an adviser could check. A team without a legal department could make that first decision for itself and take the remaining questions to the right person.
Contractam provides contract review and information, not legal advice. For advice specific to your situation, consult a qualified Australian lawyer. Contractam reviews contracts under Australian law only. See our disclaimer.


